ChatGPT vs Claude vs Gemini: a six-prompt test kit for Indian work
Short answer: For most Indian office work, ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini are all capable, and the right pick depends on the job. ChatGPT is the strongest all-rounder with the most built-in tools, Claude usually writes the most natural long-form English and reads long documents carefully, and Gemini fits best if your work lives in Gmail, Docs and Drive.
This is a head-to-head of three assistants, not a guide to every AI tool. If you want a router for images, video, slides and voice too, our post on which AI tool to use for what covers that. Here we take six prompts that mirror real Indian work, explain how to run them in all three on the same day, and show how to score what comes back.
One honest caveat up front: these models are updated every few months, so any ranking is a snapshot. The test kit below is the part that stays useful. Rerun it whenever a new version ships, and trust your own scores over any blog's, including this one.
How do you run a fair test of three AI chatbots?
Use the same prompt, on the same day, in a fresh chat, with no saved instructions shaping the answer. Many quick comparisons break at least one of these rules.
- Open a new chat in each tool on the same day. Turn off or empty custom instructions and memory for the test, otherwise you are testing your settings, not the model.
- Use the same tier in all three. Comparing a free ChatGPT account with a paid Claude account tells you about plans, not models.
- Paste the prompt exactly. Do not rephrase for one tool because its first answer was weak.
- Score each answer from 1 to 5 on four things: accuracy, usefulness for the task, tone for an Indian reader, and how many minutes of editing it needs before you would send it.
- Write the date and the model name each tool shows at the top of your scoring sheet. Without that, your scores mean nothing in three months.
In agency work, the column that decides most choices is the last one, edit time. An answer that scores 4 on accuracy but needs 15 minutes of rewriting is worse in practice than a 4 that needs two.
The six prompts to copy
Each prompt is short enough to paste and specific enough that a vague answer is obvious. The last column is what a 5 out of 5 answer must include.
| # | Task | Prompt | A 5/5 answer includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Client email | Write a polite but firm second payment reminder to a distributor in Pune. Invoice of ₹1,84,000 is 45 days overdue. Under 120 words, Indian business tone, no threats. | The amount and days overdue, a clear ask with a date, warm but not grovelling, no American idioms |
| 2 | Current facts | Explain to a kirana store owner in simple English which GST slabs apply to common household goods now, and what changed in the 2025 GST rate rationalisation. | The September 2025 move to mainly 5% and 18% slabs, advice to confirm item rates on the GST portal or with a CA, no old slab structure presented as current |
| 3 | Hinglish copy | Write 3 Instagram captions in Hinglish for a Lajpat Nagar boutique's Diwali sale, flat 30% off on suits, till 2 November. Max 5 hashtags each. | Natural Hinglish rather than translated Hindi, the offer and date in every caption, hashtags capped at five |
| 4 | Long document | Upload a 30–50 page PDF such as a tender or HR policy, then ask: list every deadline, every penalty and every decision I need to make, with page numbers. | Page numbers that actually match, nothing invented, items it could not find flagged as missing |
| 5 | Spreadsheet | Invoice Date is in column B and Paid Date in column C (blank if unpaid). Give me an Excel formula for days overdue as of today, and one that shows OVERDUE if it is more than 30 days. | Working formulas using TODAY() and IF, handles a blank Paid Date, says where to paste them |
| 6 | Research | List 5 direct competitors of a Jaipur D2C block-print bedsheet brand, with website links and one line on how each prices. | Real, checkable brands with working links and an honest note where it is unsure |
Prompt 2 checks whether a tool knows recent Indian facts or falls back on old training data. Prompt 6 is a trap on purpose: an assistant that answers without searching the web is likely to invent at least one brand or link. Click every link before you score it.
Worked example: scoring prompt 1
Here is the kind of weak first draft any of the three can produce when the prompt is loose, for example just “write a payment reminder email”:
“Dear Sir, I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to kindly remind you that your payment is pending. We would be grateful if you could clear the dues at your earliest convenience. Please do the needful. Thanks and regards.”
- Accuracy 2/5: no invoice number, no amount, no days overdue.
- Usefulness 1/5: “at your earliest convenience” invites another 45 days of silence.
- Tone 3/5: polite, but “please do the needful” reads dated even to Indian readers.
- Edit time: about 10 minutes, which is effectively a rewrite.
The full prompt in the table fixes most of this by giving the amount, the stage and a word limit. If an assistant still ignores facts you gave it, that is a real mark against it. If all three ignore them, the problem is usually the prompt, which is exactly what our guide on how to write AI prompts works through.
Claude vs ChatGPT: which is better for writing?
For long-form English that needs little editing, many writers prefer Claude; for short marketing copy in many variations, ChatGPT is usually just as good and quick to iterate. The gap is smaller than social media suggests.
- Claude tends to follow tone instructions closely and uses fewer stock phrases, which matters for proposals, blog drafts and policy documents. It also handles long pasted documents well. Our Claude walkthrough covers Projects and Artifacts.
- ChatGPT is the broader all-rounder: image generation, voice mode, file analysis, web search and custom GPTs in one place. For a freelancer who wants a single subscription, that breadth usually wins.
- Both can write Hinglish. Neither reliably gets Hindi idiom right for ads without a native speaker's edit, so budget time for that.
A pattern we see with beginners: they judge writing quality on a two-line prompt. Paste a sample of your own writing into each tool and ask it to match the style. The differences become much clearer.
Is Gemini better than ChatGPT?
Gemini is better than ChatGPT when your work sits inside Google's apps; for general chat and writing, the two are close and preference decides. Its main advantage is integration, not raw intelligence.
- On eligible Google plans, Gemini works inside Gmail, Docs, Sheets and Drive, so you can summarise a long email thread or draft a reply where you already are. Check which Workspace features your plan includes.
- It handles YouTube links and Google Search grounding naturally, which helps for quick research on Indian topics.
- If you already get Google AI Pro through a telecom or student offer, you pay nothing extra for it, which changes the maths. Our guide to getting started with Google Gemini covers setup.
Score Gemini carefully on prompts 4 and 5. Long documents and spreadsheets are exactly where Workspace users will lean on it most, so its results there matter more than its captions.
What do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini cost in India?
All three have a usable free tier, and their main paid plans sit at roughly ₹1,950–2,000 a month in India. Figures below are as of November 2026, approximate and subject to change, so check each official pricing page before you pay.
| Assistant | Free tier | Lower-cost paid plan | Main paid plan | Heavy-use plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Yes, with limits on advanced models, files and images | ChatGPT Go, about ₹399 a month | Plus, about ₹1,999 a month | Pro, many times the Plus price |
| Claude | Yes, with usage limits that reset every few hours | None below Pro | Pro, about ₹2,000 a month since Anthropic's July 2026 rupee pricing (GST included) | Max, from about ₹11,999 a month |
| Gemini | Yes, generous for everyday use | Google AI Plus, ₹399 a month (launched December 2025 with a lower introductory price) | Google AI Pro, about ₹1,950 a month, with 2 TB storage | Google AI Ultra, priced far higher where offered |
Team and business plans (OpenAI's business tiers, Claude Team, Gemini in Google Workspace) are priced per user and are a separate decision. For a closer look at ChatGPT's tiers, read ChatGPT free vs Go vs Plus. Before paying for anything, check whether you already qualify for one of the free AI subscriptions available in India through Jio, Airtel or a student offer.
Verdict: which of the three for which job
| Use this | When you need to |
|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Do many different things in one place: draft, analyse a spreadsheet, make an image, talk by voice, search the web |
| ChatGPT | Build a repeatable workflow with a custom GPT or Project |
| Claude | Write or edit long documents where tone matters: proposals, policies, reports, blog drafts |
| Claude | Read a long contract or tender carefully and answer questions about it |
| Gemini | Work inside Gmail, Docs, Sheets and Drive without copy-pasting |
| Gemini | Summarise YouTube videos or do quick research grounded in Google Search |
| Any of the three | Everyday questions, simple emails and brainstorming: use the one you already pay for |
Most professionals end up with one paid tool and one free one as a second opinion. Paying for all three is rarely worth it unless AI is central to your job. This verdict covers only these three chat assistants; for images, video, slides and voice, our task-by-task AI tool map is the better guide.
Mistakes people make when comparing AI chatbots
- Testing once. Run each prompt twice; the same tool can score a 3 and a 5 on the same prompt.
- Uploading real client files to test. Use a dummy or anonymised PDF. Client data should not go into a tool your company has not approved.
- Trusting benchmark leaderboards. They measure exam-style tasks; your six prompts measure your job.
- Ignoring habit. The tool you open without thinking beats a slightly better one you forget to use.
If you want to build this judgement with guided practice across all three, the Applied AI Professional course at Spettro School runs comparisons like these on real work tasks.
Frequently asked questions
Which AI chatbot is best overall?
There is no single winner. ChatGPT is the safest all-rounder, Claude often wins for long-form writing and document reading, and Gemini wins inside Google's apps. Run your own work prompts in each before deciding.
Is Claude better than ChatGPT?
For long, careful writing and reading big documents, many users prefer Claude. For breadth of features such as images, voice and custom GPTs, ChatGPT is ahead. The better choice depends on which of those you do daily.
Which is best for Hindi or Hinglish?
All three handle Hindi and Hinglish reasonably, and quality shifts with each update. Test with your own caption or message, and have a native speaker check ad copy before it goes live.
Can I use ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini for free?
Yes, all three have free tiers that are enough for occasional use. Limits on advanced models, file uploads and messages apply and change, so check each tool's current plan page.
Is Gemini free with Jio?
Jio has offered users on eligible unlimited 5G plans 18 months of Google AI Pro through the MyJio app, first for younger users and then for all ages. Eligibility and sign-up windows have changed since launch, so check the current offer in the app.
Keep reading in AI tools
- How to Write AI Prompts That Work First Time Start here
- How to Use ChatGPT for Beginners: From Sign-Up to Useful Results in a Week
- ChatGPT Free vs Go vs Plus: Which Plan Should You Pay For?
- Best Free AI Image Generators in 2026, and How to Test Them on Indian Images
- How to Use NotebookLM to Study and Research From Your Own Files
Related: Applied AI Professional · Which AI Tool to Use for What: The Practical Guide for Work in 2026 · All guides in AI tools