SEO Audit Step by Step: A 20-Point Self-Check With Free Tools
Short answer: An SEO audit is a structured check of whether your site can be crawled, indexed, understood and trusted. To do one step by step, review Search Console's indexing and performance reports, crawl the site with a free crawler, test speed in PageSpeed Insights, check each key page's on-page basics, then rank every issue by impact and effort.
You don't need a paid tool or an agency report to find most problems on a small site. Three free tools and a spreadsheet catch the large majority of issues on a typical 20–200 page business website. The harder part is deciding what to fix first, which is where most DIY audits stall.
Run this every three months, and after any redesign. It pulls together the checks from our technical SEO basics and the on-page SEO checklist, and sits in the review stage of the beginner's SEO plan.
What tools do you need for a free SEO audit?
Four free tools cover almost everything for a small site, as of November 2026.
- Google Search Console: indexing status, search performance, Core Web Vitals and manual actions. If you're new to it, read our Search Console guide for beginners first.
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider (free version): crawls up to 500 URLs and lists titles, headings, status codes, redirects and canonicals.
- PageSpeed Insights: speed and Core Web Vitals for individual pages, on mobile and desktop.
- A site: search on Google (type site:yoursite.com): a rough view of what Google shows from your site.
Set up a sheet with these columns before you start: Check, Finding, Pages affected, Impact (High/Medium/Low), Effort (High/Medium/Low), Owner, Done.
The 20-point audit sheet
| # | Check | Tool | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Manual actions | Search Console > Security & manual actions | Any manual action listed |
| 2 | Indexed vs submitted pages | Search Console > Pages | Important pages not indexed |
| 3 | Main reasons for non-indexing | Search Console > Pages | Large 'Crawled – currently not indexed' count |
| 4 | Sitemap status | Search Console > Sitemaps | Errors, or sitemap lists URLs that redirect or 404 |
| 5 | robots.txt | yoursite.com/robots.txt | Blocks important sections or AI search crawlers |
| 6 | HTTPS and preferred domain | Browser, crawler | http or www versions don't redirect |
| 7 | Response codes | Screaming Frog > Response Codes | Internal links to 404 or 5xx pages |
| 8 | Redirect chains | Screaming Frog > Response Codes (Redirection filter) or Reports > Redirects | Two or more hops before the final page |
| 9 | Accidental noindex | Screaming Frog > Directives | Noindex on pages you want found |
| 10 | Canonicals | Screaming Frog > Canonicals | Pointing to the wrong page |
| 11 | Title tags | Screaming Frog > Page Titles | Missing, duplicate, or all the same template |
| 12 | Meta descriptions | Screaming Frog | Missing or duplicated on key pages |
| 13 | H1 headings | Screaming Frog > H1 | Missing or several per page |
| 14 | Thin pages | Screaming Frog word count, manual review | Key pages under about 150 words of real text |
| 15 | Near-duplicate pages | Manual review, site: search | Pages that differ only by a city or product name |
| 16 | Mobile speed | PageSpeed Insights | Poor LCP or INP on main templates |
| 17 | Images | Screaming Frog > Images | Missing alt text, files over 500 KB |
| 18 | Internal links | Screaming Frog > Inlinks | Important pages with zero or one internal link |
| 19 | Structured data | Rich Results Test, Schema Markup Validator; Search Console's enhancement and Shopping reports where they exist | Invalid markup, or Product errors (LocalBusiness and Article have no dedicated Search Console report) |
| 20 | Search performance trend | Search Console > Performance, 16 months | Sharp drop in clicks or impressions |
Practitioner tip: start with rows 1, 2 and 20. A manual action or a sudden traffic drop changes the whole priority list, and there's no point polishing meta descriptions on a site with an indexing problem.
How do you crawl your site with Screaming Frog's free version?
A crawler visits your site the way a search engine does and lists every page it finds. The free version's 500-URL limit is enough for most small business sites.
- Download and open Screaming Frog SEO Spider, then type your home page URL into the bar at the top and click Start.
- When the crawl finishes, open the Response Codes tab and filter by Client Error (4xx). Note each broken URL and, using the Inlinks tab at the bottom, which pages link to it.
- Open Page Titles and filter Duplicate and Missing.
- Open H1 and filter Missing and Multiple.
- Open Directives and filter Noindex.
- Export each filtered list and paste the counts into your audit sheet.
If your site has more than 500 URLs, crawl one section at a time, such as /blog/ or /products/, using the include settings.
How do you decide what to fix first?
Rank each issue by impact (how much it affects visibility or enquiries) and effort (how long it takes to fix). Fix high-impact, low-effort issues first, schedule high-impact, high-effort ones, and leave low-impact work for later.
Here's how that grid typically looks for a small business site.
| Low effort | High effort | |
|---|---|---|
| High impact | Do this week: remove accidental noindex, fix broken internal links to key pages, add missing titles | Plan this month: rewrite thin service pages, fix slow templates, merge near-duplicate pages |
| Low impact | Batch later: missing alt text on old blog images, tidy redirect chains | Probably skip: chasing a perfect 100 PageSpeed score, rewriting every old meta description |
A common mistake we see is treating every red item in a tool report as urgent. Tools flag hundreds of things; three or four of them usually matter.
A worked example: auditing a Jaipur D2C brand's site
Say you run a Jaipur block-print bedsheet brand on Shopify with about 180 URLs. A morning's audit might produce this short list, in priority order:
- Search Console shows 40 product pages 'Crawled – currently not indexed'. Most have the same two-line manufacturer description. Fix: write unique descriptions for the top 20 sellers first. The process is in our guide to fixing crawled but not indexed pages.
- Screaming Frog finds 12 internal links to products deleted last season. Fix: redirect them to the closest live collection.
- PageSpeed shows product pages with LCP around 5 seconds on mobile, caused by 3 MB lifestyle photos. Fix: compress the images and recheck.
- Every collection page has the same title format with no product type in it. Fix: edit the titles in Shopify's search engine listing settings.
- Alt text is missing on 300 images. Fix: batch it over the next month, starting with best sellers.
Five fixes, clearly ordered, each with an owner. That's a more useful output than a 60-page PDF.
Notice what isn't on the list: chasing backlinks, rewriting the home page, or adding a blog. Those may matter later, but the audit says the immediate losses come from pages Google won't index and links that lead nowhere. Fixing the cheap, high-impact problems first also gives you a clean baseline, so the next audit in three months shows whether the bigger changes actually helped.
Should an SEO audit check AI-answer readiness?
Yes, briefly. A few extra checks tell you whether AI answer engines can find and quote your key pages, and they take about 20 minutes.
- robots.txt doesn't block OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot or Bingbot, unless you've chosen to.
- The site is verified in Bing Webmaster Tools, since Bing's index grounds Copilot.
- Each key service or product page opens with a plain, self-contained answer: what it is, who it's for, rough price range, location.
- Important facts are in text, not only in images, PDFs or videos.
- Prices, hours and addresses match across the website, Business Profile and listings.
- GA4 has an AI channel set up, so you can see whether any of this produces visits.
Add these as rows 21 onwards in your sheet if you want to track them, but score them after the core 20; an unindexed page won't be cited anywhere.
What an audit can't tell you
A DIY audit finds technical and on-page problems. It can't tell you whether your content is better than competitors', whether your prices or offers convert, or whether enough other sites trust you. Those need judgement, not a crawler.
Be wary of any audit, free or paid, that ends with a single score out of 100. Scores are a tool's opinion; Search Console data is Google's. Audits like this, using real sites, are part of our advanced digital marketing course.
Frequently asked questions
How often should I do an SEO audit?
A light audit every three months suits most small business sites, plus a full one after any redesign, platform change or sudden drop in traffic. Monthly glances at Search Console catch most problems in between.
Can I do an SEO audit without paid tools?
Yes. Search Console, Screaming Frog's free version, PageSpeed Insights and a site: search cover the important checks for sites up to about 500 URLs. Paid tools mainly add backlink and competitor data.
What is the most important part of an SEO audit?
Indexing. If key pages aren't indexed, nothing else matters for them, so check Search Console's Pages report and manual actions before anything else.
How long does an SEO audit take?
For a small site of under 200 pages, a first audit with this checklist usually takes half a day to a day. Later audits are quicker because you're comparing against the last one.
Why does my audit tool score differ from Google's data?
Audit tools use their own rules and weightings, so a score is an estimate. Search Console reflects what Google actually sees, so give it priority when the two disagree.
Keep reading in SEO and AI search
- SEO for Beginners: A Step-by-Step Plan for a Real Small-Business Site Start here
- What Is AEO and GEO, and How Are They Different From SEO?
- How to Rank Higher on Google Maps With Your Business Profile
- Google Business Profile Suspended: How to Fix It and Pass Video Verification
- How Long Does SEO Take for a New or Small Business Website?
Courses: Advanced Digital Marketing & Performance Ads · Digital Marketing Foundations · All guides in SEO and AI search